When you buy insurance, you’re paying for peace of mind—not a fight. Every insurer owes you a duty of good faith and fair dealing, which means they must fairly investigate, evaluate, and pay valid claims. When an insurer unreasonably delays, underpays, or denies a claim, that can be “bad faith.” A bad faith lawsuit can recover what the policy should have paid, plus additional damages. In serious cases, courts may award punitive damages to punish and deter misconduct.
What Is Insurance Bad Faith?
- Simple explanation: Bad faith is when an insurer treats you unfairly—like denying a valid claim without a real reason or dragging its feet without justification.
- Detailed explanation: Bad faith is more than a mistake or a close call. It’s conduct that is unreasonable, dishonest, or shows willful or reckless disregard for your rights under the policy. Laws vary by state, but common hallmarks include inadequate investigation, misrepresenting policy terms, and leveraging delay to force a low settlement.
Common Examples of Bad Faith
- Unreasonable denial without a thorough investigation
- Undue delays in acknowledging, investigating, or paying the claim
- Misrepresenting policy language or relevant facts
- Lowball offers unsupported by facts or industry standards
- Failing to defend you in a covered lawsuit (liability policies)
- Refusing reasonable settlement within policy limits, risking an excess judgment
- Pressuring you to give broad releases or unnecessary recorded statements
Note: A legitimate dispute over value or coverage—backed by a reasonable investigation—may not be bad faith.
First-Party vs. Third-Party Bad Faith
|
Aspect
|
First-Party (Your Own Claim)
|
Third-Party (Claims Against You)
|
|---|---|---|
|
Typical Policies
|
Homeowners, auto collision/UM, disability, health
|
Auto liability, commercial general liability
|
|
Insurer’s Core Duties
|
Prompt, fair investigation and payment of your loss
|
Defend you in lawsuits; reasonably settle within limits
|
|
Bad Faith Examples
|
Lowballing, delay, denial without basis
|
Refusing a reasonable settlement, exposing you to excess verdict
|
|
Damages
|
Policy benefits, consequential losses, potential emotional distress, fees (varies), punitive in some states
|
Amount above policy limits (excess), reputational/economic harm, punitive in some states
|
Denied Claim Lawsuits: What You Must Prove
- Breach of contract: The insurer failed to pay benefits owed under the policy.
- Bad faith tort (where recognized): The insurer acted unreasonably and knowingly or with reckless disregard of your rights.
- Evidence often includes: claim file notes, adjuster logs, timelines, expert reports, internal guidelines, and communications. Clear, consistent documentation is crucial.
The Typical Process
- Claim submitted and documented; insurer investigates.
- If denied or underpaid, you can appeal, escalate to a supervisor, or submit a demand letter. Some states require a formal “civil remedy notice” and a cure period.
- Lawsuit filed for breach of contract and, where supported, bad faith.
- Discovery: obtain claim file, internal policies, depositions of adjusters/supervisors, and expert opinions.
- Resolution: negotiation, mediation, or trial. If egregious misconduct is proven, punitive damages may be considered.
Damages You May Recover
- Contract benefits: The amount the insurer should have paid.
- Consequential damages: Financial losses caused by delay/denial (e.g., extra living expenses, credit harm).
- Emotional distress: Available in some states for bad faith.
- Attorney’s fees and interest: Often statute- or policy-dependent.
- Punitive damages: Reserved for serious misconduct to punish and deter.
Punitive Damages in Bad Faith Cases
- Simple explanation: Punitive damages punish insurers for intentional or reckless wrongdoing—not honest mistakes.
- Detailed explanation: Most states require “clear and convincing” proof of malicious, fraudulent, or oppressive conduct, or willful/wanton disregard for your rights. Punitive awards must be proportionate to the harm and typically stay within single-digit multiples of compensatory damages. Some states cap or restrict them, require a separate trial phase, or demand proof of high-level corporate involvement.
Key factors courts/juries consider:
- Systemic practices that prioritize profits over valid payments
- Repeated misconduct or concealment of adverse facts
- Fabricated rationales or ignoring contrary evidence
- Failure to train/supervise adjusters; quota-driven denials
- The insurer’s financial condition (to calibrate punishment)
Important: Some states limit insurance coverage for punitive damages—meaning the insurer may not be able to insure itself against punitives arising from its own misconduct.
How a Bad Faith Lawyer Helps
- Evaluates coverage, denial reasons, and claim value
- Preserves evidence (claim file, logs, recordings, metadata) and sends spoliation letters
- Prepares and serves statutory notices/demands where required
- Coordinates experts (engineering, medical, valuation, claims-handling standards)
- Navigates discovery to uncover internal policies and decision-making
- Negotiates settlements and, if needed, takes the case to trial
Fees are often contingency-based (a percentage of recovery), plus case costs. Ask about fee structures, expected timelines, and whether fee-shifting statutes may apply.
Deadlines and Time Limits
Statutes of limitations vary widely by state and claim type (contract vs. bad faith tort) and may range from about 1–4+ years. Policies can also include shorter suit-limitation clauses. Act quickly—missing a deadline can extinguish your claim.
Practical Steps If Your Claim Was Denied
- Request the denial reasons in writing, citing policy provisions.
- Ask for your claim file and all relied-upon documents and photos.
- Keep a timeline of every call, email, and request; save all letters.
- Get independent estimates or expert opinions to counter low valuations.
- Avoid signing broad releases or giving recorded statements without advice.
- Consider a regulatory complaint to your state’s insurance department.
- Consult a bad faith lawyer early to preserve rights and meet notice requirements.
FAQs
- Can I win bad faith if the insurer paid late? Possibly—if the delay was unreasonable and caused harm.
- Do I need to prove the insurer intended to harm me? Not always; reckless or willful disregard may suffice, depending on state law.
- How long does a case take? Many resolve within 6–18 months; complex cases or punitive claims can take longer.
- Are punitive damages taxed? Generally yes; consult a tax professional.
- What about employer-provided health or disability (ERISA) plans? These are often governed by federal ERISA, which typically bars bad faith tort claims and punitive damages; remedies are usually limited to benefits due, interest, and possibly fees.
When to Call a Lawyer
- You received a denial or a “lowball” offer.
- The insurer is stalling or demanding unnecessary, repetitive information.
- There’s evidence the insurer ignored facts or misrepresented policy terms.
- Your financial exposure is growing (e.g., risk of foreclosure, business interruption, medical collections).
Summary
- Bad faith occurs when insurers unreasonably deny, delay, or underpay valid claims.
- You can pursue contract benefits, consequential damages, and—in egregious cases—punitive damages.
- Strict standards and deadlines apply, and requirements vary by state.
- Early consultation with a seasoned bad faith lawyer maximizes your leverage, preserves evidence, and positions your case for full compensation.
Disclaimer: This article provides general information, not legal advice. Laws vary by state and facts. Consult a licensed attorney about your specific situation.
